Actionable reports require a comprehensive evaluation of risk
BTAM teams must conduct a comprehensive evaluation of the risk posed by the individual
Report pages 59–74: 203 claims on pp. 59–74 (fact 5, statement 96, evidence 47, conclusion 3, conjecture 4, definition 48).
BTAM teams must conduct a comprehensive evaluation of the risk posed by the individual
BTAM teams should use a fact-based process to gather information from diverse sources
The purpose of the assessment phase in BTAM is to determine whether an individual poses a risk of harm to themselves or others
NTAC found that the workplace was the most common formal setting in which concerning behavior was observed
most attackers exhibited behaviors that elicited concern in others prior to their attacks
Gathering information can be accomplished using a phased procedure beginning with a preliminary inquiry and, when appropriate, conducting a full assessment
BTAM teams should utilize the Systems Approach and explore relevant Assessment Themes
To accomplish this, BTAM teams should conduct a preliminary inquiry and/or full assessment to systematically gather information to develop a comprehensive understanding of the thinking and behaviors of the individual of concern.
In workplace settings, this process may entail gathering information from individuals and systems both inside and outside of the organization, then piecing together a comprehensive picture of the individual's behavior and life circumstances so an informed and reliable assessment of risk can be made.
Why inferred Typed statement, not conjecture: the 'may'/'might'/'can' is permissive guidance (what a team may do), not speculation about what is the case.
Figure 9 on the following pages illustrates a potential pathway for a report of concern from initial intake to case closure.
This finding highlights the key role workplaces can play in early detection.
Why inferred Typed conclusion: the sentence is the report's own judgement drawn from the finding just cited.
Move to Full Assessment
Full Assessment
Could the IOC* benefit from other resources?
a preliminary inquiry serves as the minimum level of response
The objective of the preliminary inquiry is to establish enough context to assess whether the case should be closed or elevated to a full assessment
This process may involve conducting interviews with the reporting person(s), the individual of concern, and others who are directly familiar with the individual or situation
Why inferred 'may' describes an optional method; typed as process guidance rather than conjecture.
If the preliminary inquiry reveals that the individual may pose a risk of harm or that more information is necessary to make that determination, the BTAM team should proceed with a full assessment
the reported concern is objectively concerning enough to bypass a preliminary inquiry and move immediately to a full assessment
the preliminary inquiry reveals a substantial concern
the preliminary inquiry alone did not yield enough information to make an assessment of risk
A full assessment involves gathering more detailed information from more diverse sources
A full assessment typically involves multiple interviews, records checks, reviews of publicly available social media, and analysis of employer-issued electronic devices
Gathering this information enables the BTAM team to gain a reasonable and articulable understanding of the risk posed
A process of gathering information from various community systems in order to provide a comprehensive and reliable assessment of an individual's thinking and behavior
the U.S. Secret Service pioneered the Systems Approach
This tiered approach ensures that resources are allocated appropriately and that every report receives an appropriate individualized response.
One early and necessary determination in the BTAM process is distinguishing between the need for a preliminary inquiry or a full assessment when responding to reports of concerning behavior in the workplace.
Preliminary inquiries are limited in scope and designed to quickly gather enough information to establish an understanding of the concern and the context needed to determine next steps.
Information for a preliminary inquiry may also come from additional sources, for example, a review of the individual's publicly available social media, as needed.
Why inferred Typed statement, not conjecture: the 'may'/'might'/'can' is permissive guidance (what a team may do), not speculation about what is the case.
The effectiveness of the BTAM team depends upon its ability to gather substantive information from the people and systems with whom the individual of concern interacts.
The Systems Approach allows BTAM teams to collect and synthesize pieces of information that may otherwise be siloed
In many cases, attackers had demonstrated concerning behavior at work, at home, and online before their attack
By utilizing the Systems Approach, BTAM teams can identify and synthesize information from numerous sources to make a holistic determination about the risk
This approach can also be an effective tool for identifying potential risk management strategies
Systems in a workplace can be internal components, such as security or human resources departments, or external community partners, such as law enforcement and mental health providers.
The center of the diagram represents the individual of concern who is the subject of the assessment.
The circles surrounding the individual of concern represent some of the workplace and community systems that may provide important behavioral and contextual information about the individual to inform the BTAM process.
Supervisors & Coworkers (orange)
Why inferred figure description: the label is printed in the Figure 10 graphic; the colour and the internal/external grouping are read from the figure legend, not from running text
Human Resources (orange)
Why inferred figure description: the label is printed in the Figure 10 graphic; the colour and the internal/external grouping are read from the figure legend, not from running text
Physical Security (orange)
Why inferred figure description: the label is printed in the Figure 10 graphic; the colour and the internal/external grouping are read from the figure legend, not from running text
Legal (orange)
Why inferred figure description: the label is printed in the Figure 10 graphic; the colour and the internal/external grouping are read from the figure legend, not from running text
Information Technology (orange)
Why inferred figure description: the label is printed in the Figure 10 graphic; the colour and the internal/external grouping are read from the figure legend, not from running text
Cybersecurity & Insider Threat (orange)
Why inferred figure description: the label is printed in the Figure 10 graphic; the colour and the internal/external grouping are read from the figure legend, not from running text
Law Enforcement (blue)
Why inferred figure description: the label is printed in the Figure 10 graphic; the colour and the internal/external grouping are read from the figure legend, not from running text
Mental Health (blue)
Why inferred figure description: the label is printed in the Figure 10 graphic; the colour and the internal/external grouping are read from the figure legend, not from running text
Judicial (blue)
Why inferred figure description: the label is printed in the Figure 10 graphic; the colour and the internal/external grouping are read from the figure legend, not from running text
Online & Social Media (blue)
Why inferred figure description: the label is printed in the Figure 10 graphic; the colour and the internal/external grouping are read from the figure legend, not from running text
Family & Community (blue)
Why inferred figure description: the label is printed in the Figure 10 graphic; the colour and the internal/external grouping are read from the figure legend, not from running text
orange circles represent internal systems to which a BTAM team should have immediate access, while blue circles represent external systems outside of the workplace
the general method for gathering information using the Systems Approach remains the same for all cases
employees at a software company submit a report of concern to the BTAM team about a colleague who is making increasingly agitated statements
The BTAM team determines that the individual presents a low risk for physical harm but a high risk for causing disruption at the store
these systems are almost always relevant when assessing and managing an individual of concern who is currently, or has previously been, employed by the organization
leveraging organizational systems will often be sufficient to assess and manage the risk posed
Internal systems can also have relevant information about other individuals of concern, including customers, clients, visitors, or members of the broader public
may get valuable insight into the individual's background and behaviors by speaking with their physical security professionals
how different systems may be leveraged depending on the unique characteristics of a case
his coworkers report that he has claimed he might "snap" if things don't improve at work
discovers that he is going through a difficult separation from his spouse and has had trouble adjusting to this change, which the employee's brother confirmed during a phone call
For instance, an organization's assessment of a current employee may look different and may leverage different sources of information compared to the systems used when assessing a customer.
Why inferred Typed statement, not conjecture: the 'may'/'might'/'can' is permissive guidance (what a team may do), not speculation about what is the case.
During their assessment, the BTAM team uses the Systems Approach to identify several concerns about the employee
Through coordinated outreach between the BTAM team, his supervisor, and HR, the employee has his workload reduced temporarily and is referred to the company's EAP so that he may receive counseling and support.
A major retail outlet has a frequent customer with a history of disruptive and concerning behaviors who recently made posts on social media alluding to something bad happening to the store.
The BTAM team uses the Systems Approach to gather information through interviews with employees from the store, direct the company IT department to further review the individual's publicly available social media posts, and coordinate with law enforcement to conduct a consensual interview with the individual regarding the social media posts.
The BTAM team works with local law enforcement to issue the customer a no trespass order from all physical store locations, while offering him discount codes for online shopping through the store's website.
Internal systems are systems within the organization itself.
BTAM teams should gather and examine information from a variety of internal systems
Employees who interact with the individual of concern may offer observations and information about past interactions, perceived behavioral changes, and indicators of escalating stress or hostility
Why inferred Descriptive 'may' about information sources; typed as guidance.
professionals may offer information pertaining to the individual's employment history
Physical security personnel may offer behavioral observations, details about security incidents, witness statements, building or facility access logs, and security footage
Why inferred Descriptive 'may' about information sources; typed as guidance.
Legal personnel may offer records of legal filings or complaints—such as claims of harassment, restraining orders, and prior violent incidents
IT may assist with access to system records, including login history, email communications, and internet usage
Why inferred Descriptive 'may' about information sources; typed as guidance.
Cybersecurity and insider threat professionals may offer data from user activity monitoring
Insider threat programs are designed to detect risks from trusted insiders, such as employees or contractors, who may intentionally or unintentionally cause harm
BTAM programs focus on violence against individuals in the workplace
Collaboration and partnership between these programs can enable each to perform their functions more effectively
However, both insider threat and BTAM programs are specifically designed to detect early behavioral red flags, aggregate data from multiple sources, and facilitate cross-functional collaboration.
These similarities make insider threat programs well-positioned to support BTAM teams in identifying and mitigating risk before it escalates to violence.
External systems are systems outside of the workplace
This highlights the importance of preemptively establishing collaborative relationships with those outside the organization
Coordination with law enforcement partners can be critical for organizations
Law enforcement agencies possess the legal authority, training, and operational protocols needed to safely engage with individuals outside the organization
Organizations may coordinate with law enforcement to serve or enforce a protective order or to request a welfare check
when reviewed in context with other stressors or criminal behaviors present in the individual's background
Community mental health partners can be valuable assets at nearly any stage of a behavioral threat assessment
Publicly available posts on social media, forums, or content-sharing platforms can reveal grievances, intent, or interest in violence
Social media content can also contain indicators that an individual is in crisis
Including a team member with expertise in open-source investigations can significantly enhance a BTAM team's ability to identify digital and online indicators of concern
These team members should be trained to ethically and efficiently find, gather, and analyze publicly available open-source information
These partners can offer valuable insight into potential symptoms and diagnoses, help BTAM teams understand unusual patterns of behavior, and identify avenues for evaluation and treatment
Some employees of concern, particularly those engaging in highly concerning behaviors, may also warrant the use of external systems to gather information when assessing risk.
Why inferred Typed statement: 'may also warrant the use of external systems' is guidance on when to use external systems, not a prediction.
BTAM teams may seek to gather and examine information from a variety of external systems, including the following:
Why inferred Typed statement, not conjecture: the 'may'/'might'/'can' is permissive guidance (what a team may do), not speculation about what is the case.
Publicly available court records (e.g., criminal charges, convictions, protective orders, civil lawsuits, eviction filings, bankruptcy declarations), which can be found on many judicial and governmental websites, can provide relevant context about an individual’s legal history or other stressors.
These professionals can provide assistance in a consultative capacity, leveraging their professional expertise to assess the risks posed by an individual or situation, particularly in cases where individuals may be experiencing mental health crises.
Why inferred Typed statement, not conjecture: the 'may'/'might'/'can' is permissive guidance (what a team may do), not speculation about what is the case.
Members of the community (e.g., family, friends) may offer critical insight into an individual's behavior and current circumstances
Why inferred Descriptive 'may' about information sources; typed as guidance.
Seeking to interview members of the community will typically occur by requesting the support of law enforcement and only in serious or high-risk situations
emergency contacts listed in their personnel file may help BTAM teams identify family and community members who have personal information about the individual
Why inferred Descriptive 'may' about a practical route; typed as guidance.
NTAC presented the 20 Assessment Themes that have been established by 25 years of NTAC research
Behavioral Threat Assessment Units: A Guide for State and Local Law Enforcement to Prevent Targeted Violence (2024)
Areas of inquiry that, when explored, will provide a contextual understanding of an individual's mindset, behavior, and circumstances
Assessment Themes can also help identify relevant protective factors for an individual of concern
Importantly, Assessment Themes are not intended to be used as a checklist to predict who will engage in violence
these themes allow BTAM teams to distinguish between situational behaviors, such as temporary frustrations or poor communication, and more persistent, escalating patterns of concern
There are three relevant categories of Assessment Themes: contextual themes, behavioral themes, and summative themes
these themes provide a structured framework to guide the gathering and integration of information about the individual of concern
This framework helps BTAM professionals look beyond isolated incidents and evaluate behavior in a broader context.
This approach ensures decisions are not made based on subjective judgments or initial impressions, but instead on a comprehensive and methodical review of relevant information.
Assessment Themes characterize common patterns of thinking and behavior found in the background and behavioral history of individuals who have engaged in past acts of targeted violence.
While BTAM teams gather information from the internal and external systems relevant to the individual of concern, these Assessment Themes should guide the team’s evaluation of the individual’s behaviors, personal circumstances, and relevant environmental factors which may increase, decrease, or contextualize concern.
Gathering both positive details (e.g., caring and supportive family) and negative details (e.g., familial discord and violence) about these factors will establish the context
prior NTAC research has found that many past attackers had substantial negative experiences related to these contextual themes
Significant setbacks, losses, and other life challenges that may be acute
Family dynamics or home environments that negatively impact an individual, including family discord, abuse, drug use, criminality, domestic violence
Current or previous history of mental health symptoms that negatively impact the individual, particularly when left untreated
A history of criminal behavior identified in formal records, including arrests, convictions, and other legal actions
Outside of formal records, criminal behavior may be identified during the assessment through interviews with family, friends, coworkers, classmates, and others familiar with the individual
Why inferred Hedged with 'may be identified'; typed as a process statement about sources.
A pattern of strained or conflicted relationships with family members, romantic partners, friends, coworkers, classmates, neighbors, or other members of the community
A pattern of engaging in criminal or inappropriate behavior for which the consequences were either absent or not commensurate with the behavior
Specific examples include being bullied or harassed by others, financial instability, job loss, divorce or child custody issues, and failed life aspirations.
Mental health history may or may not include prior formal diagnoses, hospitalizations, and treatment (e.g., prescription medication).
Contextual themes represent significant elements of an individual’s personal circumstances and surroundings that may impact their thinking and behavior.
positive home life factors may include supportive families, healthy relationships, and other dynamics that could support intervention strategies to mitigate risk
Criminal history may also include other criminal behavior and contacts with law enforcement and the courts that have not resulted in official legal actions.
Interpersonal difficulties may include an inability to form or sustain positive relationships with others due to the individual’s inappropriate or concerning behaviors.
the presence of these behavioral themes alone cannot predict if an individual will become violent
Any violent, threatening, or disturbing communications which may be conveyed verbally
An unusual or excessive interest in weapons, violence, gore, prior attacks, notorious killers, or other concerning topics
Particular concern should arise if the individual demonstrates an idolization of or desire to emulate past attackers
Prior acts of physical violence against people, animals, or property
A history of violence may reveal signs of an escalation in aggressive behavior, for example, moving from property crimes to crimes against persons
Why inferred Hedged with 'may reveal'; typed as conjecture.
A pattern of conduct that willfully and maliciously causes another to feel bullied, stalked, persecuted, threatened, injured, or attacked
Extreme ideological, political, or conspiratorial beliefs that advocate hate or violence
Fascination with weapons and violence can be demonstrated in a variety of ways, including stockpiling or manufacturing weapons
Extreme beliefs may be based on distortion of facts (e.g., conspiracy theories) or may advocate distrust, hatred, or the use of violence targeting others based on biases against a particular race, religion, national origin, sexual orientation, gender, or gender identity.
Central to assessing whether an individual poses a risk of targeted violence is understanding the nature of concerning behaviors commonly observed in previous attackers.
For example, if an assessment reveals an individual is fixated on past attackers, has grown increasingly isolated, and has posted concerning violent content on social media, the BTAM team will need to develop the appropriate strategies to manage the risk the individual may pose toward the workplace.
The content of the concerning communications may reveal information on threats, grievances, violent intention, feelings of hopelessness/suicidality, obsessions, paranoid thinking, or a fascination with violence or weapons.
The victim of this behavior may or may not have a pre-existing relationship with the individual of concern.
Intense or obsessive preoccupations with a person, event, activity, or belief, to the point where they negatively impact aspects of an individual's life
Fixations often carry an angry or emotional undertone
Changes in behavior observable to others, including notable shifts in mental, social, occupational, physical, or interpersonal functioning
Feeling hopeless, despondent, desperate, or out of options
may lead to feelings of extreme distress, depression, frustration, and the perception that violence is the only option to cope with their circumstances
Why inferred Hedged with 'may lead to'; typed as conjecture.
A pattern of intense or escalating anger or aggression
Evidence of unusual inconsistencies in an individual's communications and behaviors
these may be indicative of efforts to conceal violent intentions or behavior
Why inferred Hedged with 'may be indicative'; typed as conjecture.
Specific steps taken to prepare to carry out an act of violence
Individuals may also engage in final acts intended to make a statement or to prepare for their inevitable arrest or death
Why inferred Hedged with 'may also engage'; typed as conjecture about motive.
changes in mood, appearance, or hygiene; withdrawing or isolating from others; new or increased substance use; sudden aggressive, violent, or threatening behavior; changes in work or school attendance or performance; signs of depression or paranoia
impulsive angry outbursts, significant overreaction to circumstances or events, or frequent episodes of verbal or physical aggression directed at others
Specific steps taken to prepare to carry out an act of violence, including researching, visiting, or following potential targets
These acts may include drafting a last will and testament, making financial arrangements for family members, leaving farewell messages or notes, posting goodbye messages online, and selling or giving away personal possessions.
Summative themes represent key questions that must be answered as part of an overall assessment
BTAM teams will be better equipped to make an informed assessment of risk if they have identified what is, or could be, motivating someone to become violent
The individual's behaviors or communications have caused fear, alarm, worry, or distress in those who observed them
Particular attention should be paid to whether others are in fear for their safety as a result of the individual's behavior
The reason(s) why the individual engaged in the behavior that elicited concern or brought them to the attention of the BTAM team
Motives may be multifaceted and include retaliating for grievances or perceived wrongs
Current or future ability to access weapons that could be used to cause harm
Access to weapons may include those that are readily available to the individual in their home, whether secured or unsecured, as well as those accessible in the homes of relatives or friends
Why inferred Descriptive 'may include' scope statement; typed as guidance.
Family members, friends, coworkers, neighbors, law enforcement, mental health professionals, and others may have been concerned about an individual's demeanor
Lastly, BTAM teams will need to assess if the individual has the means and capability to cause harm by gathering information about the weapons the individual has access to or could potentially obtain.
Motive also includes assessing the reasons that may drive an individual to carry out an act of violence.
They will also need to understand if the people who know or have had contact with the individual have been concerned, especially if their concern is related to safety.
Figure 11 illustrates the contextual, behavioral, and summative themes that may be relevant to an assessment
Individuals of concern can exhibit characteristics or behaviors relevant to one or more assessment themes
Each assessment theme should be understood in the context of an individual's full background and behavioral history.
Lack of Consequences
Intense Anger or Aggression
Why inferred Figure 11 omits Inconsistency and Planning and Final Acts, which pp.69-70 describe as behavioral themes (11 in total); the figure thus shows 18 themes against the 20 stated on p.67.
Elicited Concern in Others
On October 18, 2017, a 37-year-old man gathered coworkers around him by calling an impromptu meeting at the manufacturing facility where he worked
management reportedly refused to intervene because the attacker was a good worker, and no action was taken
Contextual Themes
He then drew a semiautomatic pistol and shot five of his colleagues in the head, killing three and injuring two others.
The attacker was motivated by a grievance against his coworkers who frequently played pranks on others at work, of which he felt he was the victim.
including a former workplace where he likely targeted his former boss who was not there, and another location where he shot and injured a business owner he knew
Prior to his attack, the attacker experienced several stressors in his life, including financial hardship and strained relationships both inside and outside of the workplace.
In the aftermath of his assault, he was known to be paranoid, believing others were searching for him or out to get him.
To protect himself, the attacker purchased a firearm illegally due to felony convictions on his criminal record and reportedly kept the weapon with him at all times.
Additionally, the attacker had a history of threatening and concerning behaviors in his previous jobs and was terminated from these positions due to his aggressive behavior.
On one occasion, he was arrested for assaulting a coworker after he put the coworker in a chokehold, dragged him outside, and threw him to the ground so hard that the coworker lost consciousness.
In a separate incident six months before the attack, the attacker was fired from a previous job after initiating a physical altercation with his manager because he was not granted a raise that was previously discussed.
The attacker began working at the manufacturing facility about four months before the attack.
He was known to act in a paranoid, hostile, and argumentative manner and harassed his coworkers.
accusing non-English speakers of gossiping about him, using derogatory language toward them
Three years prior to his attack, he was also a victim of physical assault in a parking lot.
These behaviors were noticed by others in the workplace, and coworkers reported their concerns about the attacker's behaviors to management and requested help.
As information is gathered from interviews, records, and other sources, the BTAM team must assess whether an individual of concern poses a risk of violence
Does the individual of concern pose a risk of violence at this time?
The BTAM team should make this determination by considering all information obtained using the Systems Approach and considering relevant Assessment Themes
If the BTAM team determines that the individual of concern does pose a risk of harm, then the BTAM team should take steps to intervene and manage the risk posed
BTAM teams should ensure that each classification level is clearly defined and articulable (e.g., clarifying the distinction between low and medium risk) to avoid confusion and inconsistencies across assessments
The BTAM team's protocols should allow for the team to deviate from the ascribed level of risk
Protocols should also allow for implementing risk management resources in all cases, including those deemed low risk
Assessing risk is a dynamic and continuous process
The BTAM team should routinely assess any changes or new information that may increase, decrease, or contextualize the risk of harm posed by the individual of concern
BTAM teams may decide to implement risk management strategies to support the individual's well-being and prevent a potential escalation to violence
Organizations should develop standardized forms to provide structure and consistency in documenting the BTAM process
Preliminary inquiry forms to capture the nature of the report, sources of information that must be reviewed, initial findings, and a determination of action
Interview questionnaires to gather background information about the interview subject
Assessment forms to document sources tapped when gathering information
Some BTAM teams might prefer to classify their assessments into levels of risk (e.g., low risk, medium risk, and high risk) for case prioritization and management.
Why inferred Typed statement, not conjecture: the 'may'/'might'/'can' is permissive guidance (what a team may do), not speculation about what is the case.
Find the Perfect Training Class For You