NCIER®

Customers, Clients, Patients, and Visitors

Report pages 23–24: 26 claims on pp. 23–24 (fact 13, evidence 12, conjecture 1).

Claims in this section

Fact [V] p023-01

19 attacks were perpetrated by 20 customers, clients, patients, or visitors

There were 19 attacks perpetrated by 20 individuals known or knowable to the targeted location as customers, clients, patients, or visitors.

There were 19 attacks perpetrated by 20 individuals who were known or knowable to the targeted location as customers, clients, patients, and visitors

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p023-02

All but one (n = 19, 95%) of these attackers were male

All but one customer, client, patient, or visitor who perpetrated an attack was male (n = 19, 95%).

Sample (n = 19 of 20) · customer, client, patient, and visitor attackers

All but one (n = 19, 95%) customer, client, patient, or visitor who perpetrated an attack were male

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p023-04

Over three-quarters (79%) of these attacks were motivated at least partly by grievance

Over three-quarters (n = 15, 79%) of the 19 attacks were motivated, in whole or in part, by a grievance against an organization or its employees.

Sample (n = 15 of 19) · attacks by customers, clients, patients, and visitors

Over three-quarters (n = 15, 79%) of the 19 attacks perpetrated by customers, clients, patients, and visitors were motivated, in whole or in part, by a grievance

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p023-05

Key finding: 79% of incidents were motivated by grievances

The key findings box reports that 79% of incidents were motivated by grievances.

Sample (n = 15 of 19) · attacks by customers, clients, patients, and visitors

79% of incidents were motivated by grievances

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p023-06

Key finding: 65% engaged in concerning behavior at the location before attacking

The key findings box reports that 65% engaged in concerning behaviors at the targeted location before their attack.

Sample (n = 13 of 20) · customer, client, patient, and visitor attackers

65% engaged in concerning behaviors at the targeted location prior to their attack

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p023-07

Key finding: 60% experienced a triggering event before attacking

The key findings box reports that 60% experienced a triggering event prior to their attack.

Sample (n = 12 of 20) · customer, client, patient, and visitor attackers

60% experienced a triggering event prior to their attack

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p023-08

Attackers cited a lost match and a program expulsion as grievances

One attacker opened fire at a video game tournament shortly after losing a match, and another targeted a healthcare facility that had expelled him from a treatment program.

one attacker opened fire at a venue hosting a video game tournament shortly after he lost a match

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p023-09

Other grievances included denial of services and expulsion from a business

Other grievances included frustration over being denied services, being expelled from a business, and similar perceived slights.

Other grievances included frustration due to being denied services, being expelled from a business

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p023-10

Former treatment patient held three employees hostage for eight hours

A gunman previously treated for PTSD at a residential treatment center took five hostages, released two, and fatally shot the remaining three employees after an eight-hour standoff. One victim had expelled him from the program two weeks earlier because he had knives and threatened to kill staff.

locked himself in a room with the remaining three victims for eight hours

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p023-11

Nearly two-thirds (65%) of these attackers showed concerning behavior at the location

Nearly two-thirds (n = 13, 65%) of these attackers engaged in concerning or threatening behaviors at the targeted location before their attack.

Sample (n = 13 of 20) · customer, client, patient, and visitor attackers

Nearly two-thirds (n = 13, 65%) of the attackers who were known or knowable as customers, clients, patients, and visitors engaged in concerning or threatening behaviors at the targeted location prior to their attack

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p023-12

Prior concerning behaviors ranged from ejection for rudeness to threats to kill

Prior behaviors ranged from being ejected for erratic or rude conduct to threatening to harm or kill employees or other customers.

ranging from attackers who were ejected from the establishment due to erratic or rude behavior, to attackers who threatened to harm or kill employees or other customers

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p023-13

Newsroom attacker had harassed staff for years before opening fire

An attacker who opened fire in a newsroom office had harassed the newspaper's staff for years before the attack.

an attacker who opened fire in a newsroom office had been harassing the staff of the newspaper for years leading up to his attack

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p023-14

Customer and visitor section percentages are based on the 20 individual attackers

In the customers, clients, patients, and visitors section, percentages reflect the 20 customers, clients, patients, and visitors who perpetrated attacks.

For this section, percentages reflect those 20 customers, clients, patients, and visitors who perpetrated attacks.

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p023-15

Armed former PTSD patient took five hostages at a residential treatment center

A 36-year-old gunman armed with a rifle, a shotgun, and a bulletproof vest took five hostages at a residential treatment center where he had previously been treated for PTSD.

A 36-year-old gunman armed with a rifle, a shotgun, and a bulletproof vest took five hostages at a residential treatment center where he had previously received treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p023-16

Gunman fatally shot all three remaining hostages, then died by suicide

The attacker fatally shot the three remaining hostages before dying by suicide.

The three hostages were fatally shot by the attacker before he died by suicide.

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Conjecture [V] p023-17

Victims were staff possibly tied to his PTSD treatment; one expelled him two weeks earlier

All three victims were treatment center employees who may have had a direct connection to his prior PTSD treatment, including one who had expelled him from the program two weeks earlier because he had knives and threatened to kill staff.

All three victims were employees at the treatment center and may have had a direct connection to the attacker's prior PTSD treatment, including one victim who had expelled him from the program two weeks earlier because the attacker had knives and threatened to kill staff.

p. 23 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 23 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 23 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p024-01

Newsroom attacker killed five after grievance over an unflattering article

A man killed five people with a shotgun at a newsroom after an unflattering article about him. He had sued the paper years earlier, stalked and threatened employees, and mailed a dossier on the intended victims and their families before the attack.

The attacker had a personal grievance with the newsroom after an unflattering article was written about him

p. 24 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 24 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 24 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p024-02

Over half (60%) of these attackers appeared to have a triggering event

Over half (n = 12, 60%) of the customer, client, patient, and visitor attackers appeared to experience a specific triggering event prior to attacking.

Sample (n = 12 of 20) · customer, client, patient, and visitor attackers

Over half (n = 12, 60%) of the customer, client, patient, and visitor attackers appeared to experience a specific triggering event prior to perpetrating an attack

p. 24 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 24 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 24 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p024-03

All triggering events occurred within a month, from 2.5 hours to 2-4 weeks before

All triggering events occurred within one month of the attack, ranging from 2.5 hours to 2-4 weeks before the incident.

These triggering events all occurred within one month of the attack, ranging from 2.5 hours to 2-4 weeks prior to the incident

p. 24 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 24 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 24 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p024-04

Triggers included divorce filing, eviction, protective order, dismissed suit, and firing

The triggers included a spouse saying they were filing for divorce, an attacker being served an eviction notice or protective order, a lawsuit dismissal, and being fired from a job.

a spouse saying they were filing for divorce

p. 24 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 24 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 24 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p024-05

Newsroom attacker surveilled the building and studied police response times

Before the attack, the attacker downloaded blueprints, recorded video of the building and access points, read textbooks on mass shootings, and studied police reaction times.

downloaded blueprints and recorded video of the newsroom building and its access points, read textbooks on mass shootings, studied police reaction times to previous attacks

p. 24 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 24 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 24 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p024-06

Newsroom attacker mailed a dossier on intended victims and their families

Before the attack, the attacker created and mailed a dossier containing information about the intended victims and their families.

created and mailed a dossier with information about the intended victims and their families

p. 24 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 24 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 24 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p024-07

Newsroom attacker sold his car and bought a chess membership before prison

In preparation for incarceration after the attack, the attacker sold his car and spent a significant portion of his income on a lifetime chess organization membership.

In preparation for his incarceration after the attack, the attacker also sold his car and spent a significant portion of his income on the purchase of a lifetime membership for a chess organization.

p. 24 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 24 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 24 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p024-08

38-year-old man killed five in a newsroom with a 12-gauge pump-action shotgun

In a case example, a 38-year-old man entered a newsroom and opened fire with a 12-gauge pump-action shotgun, killing five people.

A 38-year-old man entered a newsroom and opened fire with a 12-gauge pump-action shotgun, killing five people.

p. 24 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 24 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 24 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p024-09

Newsroom attacker sued for defamation six years earlier and stalked and threatened staff

The newsroom attacker had filed a defamation lawsuit against the paper six years earlier and had stalked and threatened its employees, who contacted law enforcement and developed personal safety plans.

The attacker had filed a defamation lawsuit against the paper six years earlier and had stalked and threatened employees of the paper, prompting them to contact law enforcement and develop personal safety plans.

p. 24 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 24 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 24 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page

Top

Find the Perfect Training Class For You