NCIER®

Domestic Violence

83 claims on pp. 13–97 (fact 13, statement 22, evidence 41, conclusion 1, definition 6).

Claims about Domestic Violence

Conclusion [I] p015-06

Key findings box summarizes attacker stressors, concern, charges, and DV

The attacker key findings box lists stressors, elicited concern, prior criminal charges, and domestic violence history as key findings.

KEY FINDINGS FOR ATTACKERS

p. 15 · NCIER Claim Map

Why inferred Key findings box is a summary judgement; its statistics are restated from the body text.

Report page 15 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 15 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p016-03

Some attackers' violence against partners or relatives led to protective orders

Some attackers engaged in violence directed at romantic partners or relatives, prompting victims to seek protective or restraining orders.

some attackers engaged in violence directed at romantic partners or relatives, prompting victims to seek protective orders or restraining orders against the attackers

p. 16 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 16 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 16 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p016-05

Elementary school shooting by man with two-decade domestic violence history

A 53-year-old man killed his estranged wife and one of her students in her classroom, injuring another student, before dying by suicide. He had two decades of domestic violence, including threats to kill, and multiple people had filed restraining orders against him.

A 53-year-old man arrived at the elementary school where his estranged wife worked

p. 16 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 16 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 16 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p016-12

Only 9 of the 27 domestic violence perpetrators were arrested or charged

Only around one-third of these attackers (n = 9) were arrested or charged for such an offense.

Sample (n = 9 of 27) · attackers with at least one instance of domestic violence in their past

only around one-third of these attackers (n = 9) were arrested or charged for such an offense

p. 16 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 16 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 16 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p016-14

Gunman with two-decade criminal record killed three after protection order

A 38-year-old gunman with a two-decade criminal history, including felony convictions and domestic violence against his ex-girlfriend, was served a civil protection order at work on the day of his attack. He killed three and injured fourteen before being shot by law enforcement.

A 38-year-old gunman armed with a pistol and a rifle killed three and injured fourteen others

p. 16 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 16 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 16 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p016-15

Elementary school shooter: two decades of domestic violence and threats

The attacker's domestic violence spanned two decades and included assaults and threats to kill women, two previous wives, and his own children.

The attacker had a history of domestic violence spanning two decades, which included numerous assaults and threats to harm and kill women, including two previous wives, as well as threats to kill his own children.

p. 16 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 16 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 16 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p016-16

Elementary school shooter: motivated after estranged wife left home three months earlier

The attacker was motivated to shoot after his estranged wife moved out three months earlier and refused his attempts to force her return.

The attacker was motivated to engage in the shooting after his estranged wife moved out of his home three months earlier and refused his attempts to force her return.

p. 16 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 16 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 16 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p016-17

Gunman barred by felony convictions threatened ex-girlfriend into supplying firearms

Although barred from owning firearms by prior felony convictions, the attacker threatened his ex-girlfriend until she supplied the guns used in the attack.

Although the attacker could not legally own firearms due to his prior felony convictions, he threatened his ex-girlfriend until she provided him with the firearms he ultimately used in his attack.

p. 16 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 16 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 16 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p016-18

School shooter fired ten shots, killing his wife and a student and injuring another

At his estranged wife's classroom, the man fired ten shots from a revolver, killing his wife and one of her students and injuring another student before dying by suicide.

When he arrived at her classroom, the man drew a revolver and fired ten shots into the classroom, killing his wife and one of her students and injuring another student before dying by suicide.

p. 16 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 16 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 16 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p016-19

Ex-wives, an ex-girlfriend, and a pastor couple filed restraining orders against school shooter

The attacker's violent and threatening behavior led both of his ex-wives, an ex-girlfriend, and a local female pastor and her husband to file restraining orders against him.

The attacker's violent and threatening behavior prompted multiple parties, including both of his ex-wives, an ex-girlfriend, and a local female pastor and her husband, to file restraining orders against him.

p. 16 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 16 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 16 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p016-23

Gunman's domestic violence against ex-girlfriend led her to seek the protection order

The gunman had numerous law enforcement encounters for domestic violence against his ex-girlfriend, which prompted her to file for the protection order served on the day of his attack.

The attacker had numerous other encounters with law enforcement for domestic violence he perpetrated against his ex-girlfriend, prompting her to file for the protection order he was served on the day of his attack.

p. 16 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 16 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 16 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p025-10

Gunman killed ex-girlfriend and coworker at her healthcare workplace despite protection order

A gunman took hostages outside a healthcare center where his ex-girlfriend worked, shot and killed a police chief, then fatally shot his ex-girlfriend and her coworker before dying by suicide. He had assaulted and threatened her multiple times, and one protection order was still in place at the time of the attack.

In the months prior to the incident, he had assaulted and threatened to kill his ex-girlfriend multiple times

p. 25 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 25 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 25 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p025-11

Over three-quarters (78%) had threatened partners or relatives before attacking

Over three-quarters (n = 7, 78%) of these attackers had threatened romantic partners or family members and engaged in at least one act of domestic violence before the attack.

Sample (n = 7 of 9) · attacks by current or former romantic partners or relatives (9 attacks, each by a lone attacker)

over three-quarters of these attackers (n = 7, 78%) had a history of making threatening statements toward romantic partners or family members

p. 25 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 25 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 25 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p025-12

Key finding: 78% of attackers had a history of domestic violence

The key findings box reports that 78% of attackers had a history of domestic violence.

Sample (n = 7 of 9) · attacks by current or former romantic partners or relatives (9 attacks, each by a lone attacker)

78% of attackers had a history of domestic violence

p. 25 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 25 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 25 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p025-13

Only three of these attackers faced criminal charges for domestic violence

Only three of these attackers faced criminal charges for their acts of domestic violence.

Sample (n = 3 of 7) · romantic-partner or relative attackers with a history of threats and domestic violence

only three of these attackers faced criminal charges for their acts of domestic violence

p. 25 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 25 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 25 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p025-17

One domestic-grievance attacker targeted divorce attorneys and child-custody evaluators

One attacker motivated by a domestic grievance did not target a romantic partner's current workplace, but instead targeted the attorneys handling his divorce and the mental health professionals who had evaluated his child during a custody dispute.

One attacker motivated by a domestic grievance did not target a romantic partner's current place of employment, but instead targeted attorneys handling his divorce and mental health professionals who had conducted evaluations of the attacker's child during a custody dispute.

p. 25 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 25 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 25 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p025-20

Gunman killed his ex-girlfriend and her coworker, then died by suicide

The gunman then entered the healthcare facility and fatally shot his ex-girlfriend and her coworker before dying by suicide.

The gunman then entered the healthcare facility and fatally shot his ex-girlfriend and her coworker before dying by suicide.

p. 25 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 25 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 25 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p036-10

Figure 5 third-party vendor: high use, excellent quality, limited referrals via BTAM team

In the sample inventory, a third-party vendor assists domestic violence victims with mental health, finances, moving, lodging, and more; use is high with a finite number of contracted referrals, and quality excellent. Gaps are referral-only access via the BTAM team, limited referrals, and possible growth in need; actions are to audit budget and costs to consider renewing and expanding the contract and to evaluate supplementary community resources.

**Third-Party Vendor for Employee Services** Offers assistance to victims of domestic violence, including help with mental health, finances, moving, lodging, and more. | **High** Frequently used; contract allows a finite number of referrals. | **Excellent** Employees who have received services report they were highly beneficial. | • Only available via referral from BTAM team. • Limited number of referrals available. • Needs for services may increase due to growing workforce. | • Audit budget and costs to consider renewing and expanding contract with vendor. • Evaluate similar community resources that can supplement services.

p. 36 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 36 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 36 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p052-01

Definition: intimate partner violence (IPV)

IPV is abuse or aggression in a romantic relationship, including current and former spouses and dating partners, and can include physical, psychological, or sexual violence and stalking.

Intimate partner violence (IPV) is abuse or aggression that occurs in the context of a romantic relationship

p. 52 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 52 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 52 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p052-02

IPV ranges from a single episode to chronic violence over years

The frequency and severity of IPV vary, from a single episode to chronic and severe violence spanning multiple years. (endnote 8)

The frequency and severity of IPV varies, ranging from a single episode of violence to chronic and severe instances of violence spanning multiple years.

p. 52 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 52 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 52 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p052-04

41% of public mass attackers had a prior domestic violence history

In Mass Attacks in Public Spaces: 2016-2020 (2023), NTAC found that 41% of individuals who engaged in mass attacks in public or semi-public spaces, including workplaces, had a prior history of domestic violence, including intimate partner violence.

Sample (n = undeterminable of undeterminable) · NTAC Mass Attacks in Public Spaces: 2016-2020 (2023), a different study

41% of individuals who engaged in mass attacks in public or semi-public spaces, including workplaces, had a prior history of domestic violence

p. 52 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 52 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 52 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p052-06

29% of mass attackers were motivated at least partly by domestic grievance

In the same 2023 NTAC study, mass attackers in 29% of incidents were motivated at least in part by a domestic grievance.

Sample (n = undeterminable of undeterminable) · NTAC Mass Attacks in Public Spaces: 2016-2020 (2023), a different study

In 29% of the incidents, mass attackers were motivated to carry out their attack, at least in part, by a domestic grievance.

p. 52 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 52 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 52 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p052-08

IPV costs exceed $8.3 billion per year

According to the CDC, the estimated total cost of IPV, including medical care, mental health services, and lost productivity, exceeds $8.3 billion per year. (endnote 9)

the estimated total cost of IPV—including medical care, mental health services, and lost productivity—exceeds $8.3 billion per year

p. 52 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 52 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 52 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p052-17

Organizations must act immediately when violence in a relationship is suspected

Organizations must take immediate action if an employee is believed to be experiencing violence in a relationship.

Organizations must take immediate action if an employee is believed to be experiencing violence in a relationship

p. 52 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 52 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 52 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p052-19

Offer internal and third-party counseling and mental health services

Organizations can offer internal and third-party services, including counseling and mental health care, to victims.

Offer internal and third-party services, including counseling and mental health care

p. 52 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 52 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 52 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p052-26

IPV can include physical violence, psychological aggression, sexual violence, and stalking

Intimate partner violence can include physical violence, psychological aggression, sexual violence, stalking, and other behaviors.

IPV can include physical violence, psychological aggression, sexual violence, stalking, and other behaviors.

p. 52 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 52 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 52 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p053-03

IPV therapist: stalking and monitoring tend to be common red flags at work

The therapist says stalking and monitoring behaviors tend to be the most common red flags when someone is reporting IPV at work.

Stalking and monitoring behaviors tend to be the most common red flags when someone is reporting IPV at work.

p. 53 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 53 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 53 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Statement [V] p053-08

Victims can get help through the National Domestic Violence Hotline

Anyone experiencing domestic violence can get help through the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-SAFE (7233) or by texting START to 88788.

help is available via the National Domestic Violence Hotline

p. 53 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 53 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 53 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p053-10

IPV therapist: victims have often tried many things already, so avoid assumptions

The therapist says victims have usually tried many approaches already, so making assumptions and listing tips wastes time.

Usually, they've tried a plethora of things already, and you'd be wasting your time by making assumptions and listing off tips.

p. 53 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 53 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 53 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p053-13

IPV therapist: when victims come forward, follow their lead with safety in mind

When victims do come forward, the therapist's practice follows the victim's lead with safety in mind.

When they do come forward, we follow the victim's lead with safety in mind.

p. 53 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 53 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 53 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p053-16

IPV therapist: make a safety plan with victims to achieve their goals

A therapist who supports IPV victims says that when victims come forward, the practice makes a safety plan with them to achieve their goals.

We make a safety plan with them to achieve their goals.

p. 53 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 53 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 53 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p053-17

IPV therapist: nonjudgmental listening gives victims space to talk and allows honesty

A therapist who supports IPV victims says hearing the person out with a nonjudgmental stance gives them the space to talk about these things and allows for honesty.

It gives them the space to talk about these things and allows for honesty

p. 53 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 53 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 53 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p053-18

IPV therapist: do the opposite of the abuser and give feedback on what victims do well

A therapist who supports IPV victims says that, because abusive relationships are disempowering, practitioners must do the opposite in small ways and provide feedback on what victims are doing well.

we must do the opposite, and provide feedback on what they're doing well

p. 53 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 53 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 53 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p054-01

Global corporation BTAM leader: common cases involve suicidal ideation and crisis

A BTAM team leader at a global corporation says common cases include suicidal ideation, individual crises, difficulty managing work, and domestic violence.

A lot of what we tend to see are cases involving suicidal ideation, someone going through an individualized crisis

p. 54 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 54 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 54 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p054-10

Global corporation BTAM leader sees domestic and intimate partner violence in all regions

A BTAM team leader at a global corporation says the team also sees issues with domestic violence and intimate partner violence in all of its regions across the globe.

We also see issues with domestic violence and intimate partner violence in all of our regions across the globe.

p. 54 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 54 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 54 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p068-04

Home life covers family dysfunction, abuse and domestic violence

Home life refers to family dynamics or home environments that negatively impact an individual, including discord, abuse, drug use, criminality, and domestic violence.

Family dynamics or home environments that negatively impact an individual, including family discord, abuse, drug use, criminality, domestic violence

p. 68 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 68 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 68 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p069-05

History of violence covers prior physical violence against people or property

History of violence is prior physical violence against people, animals, or property, including assaults, domestic violence, animal cruelty, and arson.

Prior acts of physical violence against people, animals, or property

p. 69 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 69 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 69 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p094-26

Domestic grievance motive: all 22%, employees 14%, customers 5%, partners/relatives 78%

Data Table 1 reports a domestic grievance (a sub-row of grievance) as a motive in 22% of all attacks (n = 50), 14% of attacks by current or former employees (n = 22), 5% by customers, clients, patients, and visitors (n = 19), and 78% by romantic partners and relatives (n = 9).

Sample (N = 50 | 22 | 19 | 9 by column) · Data Table 1 columns: all attacks 50 | employees 22 | customers, clients, patients, visitors 19 | partners and relatives 9

Domestic | 22% | 14% | 5% | 78%

p. 94 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 94 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 94 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Definition [V] p095-03

History of domestic violence means at least one incident, with or without arrest or charge

In Data Table 2, history of domestic violence indicates at least one incident of domestic violence, which may or may not have resulted in an arrest or criminal charge.

*Indicates at least one incident of domestic violence which may or may not have resulted in an arrest or criminal charge.

p. 95 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 95 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 95 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p095-14

Domestic violence arrests/charges: all 18%, employees 9%, customers 20%, partners/relatives 33%

Data Table 2 reports arrests/charges for domestic violence for 18% of all attackers (n = 51), 9% of current or former employees (n = 22), 20% of customers, clients, patients, and visitors (n = 20), and 33% of romantic partners and relatives (n = 9).

Sample (N = 51 | 22 | 20 | 9 by column) · Data Table 2 columns: all attackers 51 | employees 22 | customers, clients, patients, visitors 20 | partners and relatives 9

Domestic Violence | 18% | 9% | 20% | 33%

p. 95 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 95 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 95 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p095-18

History of domestic violence: all 53%, employees 41%, customers 55%, partners/relatives 78%

Data Table 2 reports a history of domestic violence for 53% of all attackers (n = 51), 41% of current or former employees (n = 22), 55% of customers, clients, patients, and visitors (n = 20), and 78% of romantic partners and relatives (n = 9).

Sample (N = 51 | 22 | 20 | 9 by column) · Data Table 2 columns: all attackers 51 | employees 22 | customers, clients, patients, visitors 20 | partners and relatives 9

**History of Domestic Violence*** | 53% | 41% | 55% | 78%

p. 95 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 95 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 95 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page

Top

Find the Perfect Training Class For You