Individual of concern: concerning behaviors that may signal potential harm
Any individual who has exhibited concerning behaviors that may indicate a potential risk of harm to themselves or others in the workplace setting.
104 claims on pp. 7–95 (fact 17, statement 39, evidence 30, conclusion 1, conjecture 4, definition 13).
Any individual who has exhibited concerning behaviors that may indicate a potential risk of harm to themselves or others in the workplace setting.
Actions or communications by an individual that are objectively or contextually troubling or inappropriate and indicate a potential risk of violence.
For many employees, this includes recognizing and reporting concerning behaviors they observe so action can be taken to intervene before violence can occur.
Upon arrival, he began to yell, and insisted that he see the employee he saw on his last visit.
Sample (n = 40 of 51) · attackers, all affiliation types
78% of attackers had a history of behaviors that elicited concern from others.
Other behaviors that elicited concern included attackers making disturbing or threatening statements, exhibiting strange or unusual behaviors, and stalking and harassing others.
In the months prior to his attack, the attacker created and shared videos glorifying school shootings, and described his admiration of past attackers and his plans for his attack in numerous journal entries.
For example, one attacker accused his wife of collaborating with the government to spy on him
Sample (N = 22) · current or former employee attackers (22 attacks, each by a lone attacker)
Table 5: Performance and Conduct
Sample (n = 10 of 22) · current or former employee attackers (22 attacks, each by a lone attacker)
Over two-fifths (n = 10, 45%) of employee attackers had known substantive issues pertaining to their behavioral conduct at the workplace they attacked.
Behavioral conduct refers to actions taken by employees in the workplace, including how they interact with colleagues and others at work, and whether they adhere to an organization's policies or standards for behavior.
persistent patterns of callous, reckless, paranoid, confrontational, aggressive, and/or threatening behaviors toward others
For most of these attackers (n = 7), their misconduct could be characterized as toxic
This included making racist, derogatory, or even threatening statements towards their colleagues.
Two of these attackers exhibited toxic behavior in other organizations as well.
Three attackers exhibited behaviors that were not considered toxic but still represented issues with conduct, including chronic absences or tardiness.
Information on conduct could not be found for four employee attackers.
A 45-year-old gunman opened fire with a pistol at his former workplace, killing five of his former coworkers before dying by suicide.
Sample (n = 8 of 22) · current or former employee attackers (22 attacks, each by a lone attacker)
Good standing | 8 | 36%
Sample (n = 7 of 22) · current or former employee attackers (22 attacks, each by a lone attacker)
Toxicity | 7 | 32%
Sample (n = 13 of 20) · customer, client, patient, and visitor attackers
65% engaged in concerning behaviors at the targeted location prior to their attack
Sample (n = 13 of 20) · customer, client, patient, and visitor attackers
Nearly two-thirds (n = 13, 65%) of the attackers who were known or knowable as customers, clients, patients, and visitors engaged in concerning or threatening behaviors at the targeted location prior to their attack
ranging from attackers who were ejected from the establishment due to erratic or rude behavior, to attackers who threatened to harm or kill employees or other customers
an attacker who opened fire in a newsroom office had been harassing the staff of the newspaper for years leading up to his attack
an individual of concern is any individual who has exhibited concerning behaviors that may indicate a potential risk of harm to themselves or others in the workplace setting.
cite page 30 Part 2: A Guide for Workplace Violence Prevention
Acting at the first sign of concerning behavior, instead of waiting for a direct or explicit threat, improves the chances of preventing violence.
cite page 31 Part 2: A Guide for Workplace Violence Prevention
STEP 4 | Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
cite page 32 Part 2: A Guide for Workplace Violence Prevention
Having a dedicated policy for the BTAM program can help to create a more comprehensive prevention program capable of addressing a continuum of behaviors and concerns.
cite page 40 Step 2: Establish BTAM Program Policy and Procedures
state that the program encompasses work to proactively address any behavior that indicates a potential risk to safety and is not limited to explicit or direct threats.
cite page 41 Step 2: Establish BTAM Program Policy and Procedures
Establish parameters for when the BTAM team will convene and respond to a report. The policy should allow for a low threshold of concern
cite page 42 Step 2: Establish BTAM Program Policy and Procedures
a person may pose a risk of violence without making an explicit threat
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
concerning behaviors occur along a continuum from contextually concerning to objectively concerning
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Actions or communications by an individual that are objectively or contextually troubling or inappropriate and indicate a potential risk of violence.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
and include non-criminal and criminal activities
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Concerning behaviors may include escalating interpersonal disputes, grievances, concerning social media content, stalking and harassment, obsessions with violence, idolizing past attackers, fixating on people or locations, suicidal ideations, self-harm, unusual levels of aggression, threats, weapons violations, and physical assaults.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Some behaviors are objectively concerning (e.g., unauthorized weapons, threats, assaults) and should warrant immediate action, oftentimes including local law enforcement intervention.
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Other behaviors are contextually concerning, in that they may not prompt immediate safety concerns but should be assessed in the full context of the individual's situation and their environment
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
from contextually concerning to objectively concerning (see Figure 8)
cite page 50 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Changes in behavior, including decreased productivity, increased absenteeism, decreased attention to personal hygiene and appearance, or withdrawal from social circles
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Challenges with mental health, such as depressed mood, paranoia, or anxiety
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Intense or abnormal emotional outbursts
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Pattern of strained or conflicted relationships with colleagues
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Questionable activity on work-issued devices, such as attempting to access prohibited sites or searching for inappropriate content
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Bullying or harassing others
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Preoccupation with violent themes, such as terroristic acts or mass shootings
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Intimidating, belligerent, or other aggressive behavior
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Direct or veiled threats
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Physical violence toward people, animals, or property
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Sexual assault or harassment
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Bringing or brandishing a weapon in the workplace
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Employees should also be provided with specific examples of the types of behavior that may prompt these concerns.
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Fixations on perceived grievances
cite page 51 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
It is essential for organizations to maintain a low threshold of concern for initiating a behavioral threat assessment and not limit their focus solely to explicit threats of violence.
cite page 54 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Utilizing a low threshold of concern allows BTAM teams to identify individuals eliciting safety concerns before their behavior escalates to the point where there is an imminent risk of harm.
cite page 54 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
may illustrate individual or environmental factors that, if unaddressed, could contribute to an increased possibility of harm to self or others
Why inferred Hedged with 'may illustrate' and 'could contribute', so typed as conjecture.
cite page 54 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
It is best practice to use a low threshold of concern during the BTAM process, not to label an individual as a potential threat, but to allow for early intervention.
cite page 54 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
In a recent meeting, the employee's supervisor asked the employee what was happening.
cite page 54 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
The employee remarked that he did not know what the supervisor meant by the question and denied seeing any problems with his recent performance.
cite page 54 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
In the weeks since that meeting with his supervisor, the employee has begun to call in sick to work with increasing frequency, and when he does show up for work, his appearance has become increasingly unkempt.
cite page 54 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
The supervisor is worried about the wellness and safety of the employee.
cite page 54 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
Cybersecurity and IT professionals may set up mechanisms to alert the BTAM team to anomalous digital behaviors
cite page 56 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
employees who visit blocked or forbidden websites on multiple occasions or log onto their devices at unusual times
cite page 56 Step 4: Identify and Process Reports of Concerning Behavior
NTAC found that the workplace was the most common formal setting in which concerning behavior was observed
In many cases, attackers had demonstrated concerning behavior at work, at home, and online before their attack
During their assessment, the BTAM team uses the Systems Approach to identify several concerns about the employee
A major retail outlet has a frequent customer with a history of disruptive and concerning behaviors who recently made posts on social media alluding to something bad happening to the store.
these themes allow BTAM teams to distinguish between situational behaviors, such as temporary frustrations or poor communication, and more persistent, escalating patterns of concern
the presence of these behavioral themes alone cannot predict if an individual will become violent
Any violent, threatening, or disturbing communications which may be conveyed verbally
An unusual or excessive interest in weapons, violence, gore, prior attacks, notorious killers, or other concerning topics
Particular concern should arise if the individual demonstrates an idolization of or desire to emulate past attackers
Prior acts of physical violence against people, animals, or property
A history of violence may reveal signs of an escalation in aggressive behavior, for example, moving from property crimes to crimes against persons
Why inferred Hedged with 'may reveal'; typed as conjecture.
A pattern of conduct that willfully and maliciously causes another to feel bullied, stalked, persecuted, threatened, injured, or attacked
Extreme ideological, political, or conspiratorial beliefs that advocate hate or violence
Fascination with weapons and violence can be demonstrated in a variety of ways, including stockpiling or manufacturing weapons
Extreme beliefs may be based on distortion of facts (e.g., conspiracy theories) or may advocate distrust, hatred, or the use of violence targeting others based on biases against a particular race, religion, national origin, sexual orientation, gender, or gender identity.
Central to assessing whether an individual poses a risk of targeted violence is understanding the nature of concerning behaviors commonly observed in previous attackers.
In the aftermath of his assault, he was known to be paranoid, believing others were searching for him or out to get him.
Additionally, the attacker had a history of threatening and concerning behaviors in his previous jobs and was terminated from these positions due to his aggressive behavior.
On one occasion, he was arrested for assaulting a coworker after he put the coworker in a chokehold, dragged him outside, and threw him to the ground so hard that the coworker lost consciousness.
The BTAM team should also consider whether the individual is complying with interventions, engaging with programming, and exhibiting any changes in mood, mental state, or behavior.
Issue written or verbal warnings to individuals to articulate the organization's concerns, expectations for the individual's behavior, and what actions the organization will take if the individual continues to engage in a concerning manner.
Using behavioral agreements with patients who have exhibited aggression to outline appropriate behavioral conduct and consequences for violating the agreement.
When used appropriately, these strategies can be helpful in identifying patterns of hostile, concerning, inappropriate, criminal, or violent behaviors.
Why inferred Hedged with 'can be helpful'; classified as conjecture.
cite page 87 Step 7: Promote a Safe and Supportive Organizational Climate
If unaddressed, these problems can escalate, causing further disruption or even violence.
Why inferred Hedged with 'can escalate'; classified as conjecture.
cite page 87 Step 7: Promote a Safe and Supportive Organizational Climate
information on the types of behaviors to report
We taught them how we don't want to wait for someone to punch someone else.
This publication offers both research and guidance intended to help organizations and their partners recognize concerning behaviors and intervene before violence can occur.
Sample (N = 51 | 22 | 20 | 9 by column) · Data Table 2 columns: all attackers 51 | employees 22 | customers, clients, patients, visitors 20 | partners and relatives 9
**Concerning Communications** | 75% | 77% | 65% | 89%
Sample (N = 51 | 22 | 20 | 9 by column) · Data Table 2 columns: all attackers 51 | employees 22 | customers, clients, patients, visitors 20 | partners and relatives 9
**Inappropriate Interest in Violence or Weapons** | 10% | 9% | 10% | 11%
Sample (N = 51 | 22 | 20 | 9 by column) · Data Table 2 columns: all attackers 51 | employees 22 | customers, clients, patients, visitors 20 | partners and relatives 9
**Behavior Change** | 41% | 55% | 25% | 44%
Find the Perfect Training Class For You