NCIER®

Mental Health

33 claims on pp. 7–132 (fact 22, statement 1, evidence 6, conclusion 2, conjecture 2).

Claims about Mental Health

Evidence [V] p024-05

Kentucky, Nevada, and Oregon required BTAM by 2019 and stress multidisciplinary teams

Other states that required BTAM in schools as early as 2019, such as Kentucky, Nevada, and Oregon, also specifically stress the importance of multidisciplinary teams in the threat assessment process, with added emphasis on the role of mental health professionals.

p. 24 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 24 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 24 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p039-01

BTAM teams would respond to serious concerns such as self-harm, suicide risk, violence fixations

schools’ BTAM teams would respond to other serious concerns, such as students at risk of self-harm or suicide or students with fixations on past school violence incidents or interest in violence or extremist movements.

p. 39 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 39 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 39 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p041-14

Models most commonly recommend administration, mental health services and public safety members

Most commonly, BTAM models or implementation guidance recommend including individuals from school administration (e.g., a principal or assistant principal), mental health services (e.g., a counselor or school psychologist), and public safety (e.g., a school resource officer [SRO] or another individual with security expertise).

p. 41 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 41 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 41 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p042-16

Psychologists on 49 percent, instructional staff 45 percent, special education specialists 43 percen

Sample (N = 1408) · Schools with an official BTAM team (82 percent of sample)

Other individuals were also commonly included on BTAM teams, such as school psychologists (49 percent), instructional staff (45 percent), and special education specialists (43 percent).

p. 42 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 42 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 42 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p042-20

Majority of schools with a psychologist on team had one on staff full or part time (43 percent of sc

Sample (N = 1408) · Schools with an official BTAM team (82 percent of sample)

The majority of schools with a psychologist on their teams indicated they had a psychologist on staff at school either full time or part time (43 percent of schools overall)

p. 42 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 42 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 42 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Conclusion [V] p043-02

Authors say 6 percent figure indicates those schools made extra effort to draw personnel from outsid

this indicates that these schools made the extra effort to ensure that these disciplines were represented on the team, even though it required them to draw personnel from outside their current staffing.

p. 43 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 43 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 43 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Conjecture [V] p043-03

Same pattern for all health professional positions suggests school staffing shapes team inclusion

We saw this same pattern with all the health professional positions we asked about, suggesting that schools’ access to school-based mental and physical health staff usually shapes whether their BTAM team includes such personnel.

p. 43 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 43 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 43 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Conclusion [V] p043-04

Schools have differential access to school-based personnel; outside access can be challenging

This is noteworthy because schools have differential access to various types of school-based personnel, and accessing those disciplines from outside the school can be challenging, especially when it comes to individuals with specialized expertise.

p. 43 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 43 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 43 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p043-19

Note: 2021–2022 federal data show high-poverty schools more likely to have mental health assessment

Federal government data from the 2021–2022 school year paint a somewhat different picture, showing that high-poverty schools were actually more likely than low-poverty schools to have both diagnostic mental health assessment services and mental health treatment services (NCES, 2024).

p. 43 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 43 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 43 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p044-03

Staff at school full/part time: counselor 89 percent, nurse 89 percent, psychologist 67 percent, swo

Sample (N = 1746) · All principals, staff available at school question

Unsurprisingly, we found that some types of staff were much more common than others, with principals reporting as follows: school counselor (89 percent), school nurse (89 percent), school psychologist (67 percent), sworn law enforcement officer (58 percent), social worker (56 percent), and security guard (22 percent).

p. 44 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 44 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 44 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p067-14

Private-provider mental health counseling has a cost depending on means or insurance

For example, mental health counseling through a private provider has a cost, and how much a family might have to pay to access such services will be determined by whether they have financial means or relevant medical insurance coverage.

p. 67 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 67 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 67 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p067-19

Mental health counseling is described as the most frequently used intervention and potentially highe

As shown in Figure 9.1 mental health counseling or care is the most frequently used intervention in the broader list of intervention options and also potentially one of the higher-cost intervention options recommended by a BTAM team.

p. 67 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 67 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 67 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [I] p068-01

Three-quarters of principals: BTAM program provides free mental health counseling or care

Sample (N = 1374) · Appendix A table base (respondents answering the table question; see note for tables)

mental health counseling or care to students free of charge, either at school or by placing the student in an outside program.

p. 68 · NCIER Claim Map

Why inferred The sentence crosses a page break: this quote is the page 68 part and the sentence begins on page 67. Full sentence (pages 67–68): “Three-quarters of principals indicated that their schools’ BTAM program provides mental health counseling or care to students free of charge, either at school or by placing the student in an outside program.”

Report page 68 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 68 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p068-05

2023–2024 federal data: 84 percent of public schools provided mental health interventions; 63 percen

Sample (no n: a percentage change, not a share of a sample) · a percentage that is not a share of a sample (e.g. a percentage-point change or a weighted estimate of the population)

Federal government data for the 2023–2024 school year show that 84 percent of public schools provided mental health interventions for students, and 63 percent of schools used district or school funding to support these mental health services.

p. 68 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 68 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 68 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p068-06

Only 9 percent of schools strongly agree they can effectively provide mental health services for all

Sample (no n: a percentage change, not a share of a sample) · a percentage that is not a share of a sample (e.g. a percentage-point change or a weighted estimate of the population)

However, only 9 percent of schools “strongly agree” that they are able to effectively provide these services for all students in need (NCES, 2025).

p. 68 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 68 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 68 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Fact [V] p077-10

About a quarter of principals named counselors as first decisionmaker in elementary Scenarios D, E

Sample (N = 148 total; column N not printed) · Scenario D respondents (observations)

For certain scenarios (such as Scenario D [explicit threat, history of academic issues, withdrawal or depression] and Scenario E [violence fixation, history of academic issues, withdrawal or depression, concerning home context] at the elementary school level), about a quarter of principals identified school counselors as the first decisionmaker.

p. 77 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 77 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 77 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page
Evidence [V] p083-05

Mental health counseling prominence called somewhat unsurprising given post-COVID youth distress

This is somewhat unsurprising given heightened rates of depression and anxiety among youth following the COVID-19 pandemic and the associated rise in students seeking mental health services (Mahnken, 2023).

p. 83 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 83 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 83 · click to enlarge · all claims on this page

Top

Find the Perfect Training Class For You