NCIER®

Adoption Reasons

94 claims on pp. 22–144 (fact 85, statement 5, conclusion 1, conjecture 3).

Claims about Adoption Reasons

Conjecture [V] p028-15

State policy is not expected to be the primary determinant, but encouragement or funding could promo

Although we do not expect state policy context to be the primary determinant of schools’ decisions about which safety measures to implement (see Chapter 7 for a discussion of the primary drivers for initial BTAM implementation in schools), encouraging the use of BTAM or providing other supports, such as funding to state-level school safety agencies specifically for BTAM could promote adoption or influence how schools form BTAM teams and scope their responsibilities.

p. 28 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 28 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 28 · click to enlarge
Fact [V] p054-01

Adoption analysis covers 50 percent of principals (n = 866) present at initial implementation

Sample (n = 866 of 1746) · All principals who completed the survey and received a weight (weighted to national K-12 public school principals/schools)

we focus on the 50 percent of principals in our sample (n = 866) who said they were at their current school for that school’s initial implementation of BTAM

p. 54 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 54 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 54 · click to enlarge
Fact [V] p054-04

59 percent of principals selected best practice for violence prevention as a main driver of adoption

Sample (N = 452) · Principals answering the implementation drivers question

The perception that BTAM is a best practice for violence prevention topped the list of reasons why schools implemented BTAM in the first place: 59 percent of principals selected this option as a main driver.

p. 54 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 54 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 54 · click to enlarge
Fact [V] p054-06

Other drivers: liability 11 percent, outside organizations 8 percent, school community 5 percent

Sample (N = 452) · Principals answering the implementation drivers question

Few respondents selected other reasons as main drivers: Only 11 percent of principals reported that their school had concerns about being held liable in cases of school violence; 8 percent said that other organizations on which their school depends (e.g., local law enforcement) encouraged them to adopt a BTAM program; and 5 percent said their school community wanted them to adopt a BTAM program.

p. 54 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 54 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 54 · click to enlarge
Fact [V] p054-10

Principals in early-mandate or early-encouragement states saw policy as a driver

Sample (N = 452 total; column N not printed) · Principals answering the implementation drivers question

Interestingly, principals in states that mandated BTAM early (i.e., in 2019) or strongly encouraged its adoption early (also in 2019) perceived that such policies were a driver for BTAM adoption at their schools (e.g., half of the principals in states with early legislation said that state or local law was a main driver in their decision to implement BTAM) (see the purple box in Figure 7.1).

p. 54 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 54 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 54 · click to enlarge
Statement [V] p054-11

Principals were asked about personal involvement in initial implementation of a named or local model

We asked all principals whether they were personally involved in the initial implementation of their school’s BTAM model and whether they reported using a named BTAM model or one that was locally created for their context.

p. 54 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 54 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 54 · click to enlarge
Fact [V] p055-05

Other organizations encouraged adoption: other states 8, encouraged 10, early legislation 8 (%)

Sample (N = 452 total; column N not printed) · Principals answering the implementation drivers question

Other organizations we depend on (e.g., our local law enforcement department) encouraged us to adopt a BTAM program | 8 | 10 | 8

p. 55 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 55 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 55 · click to enlarge
Statement [V] p055-08

Figure 7.1 note: main-drivers question (n = 452), select up to three

Sample (N = 452) · Principals answering the implementation drivers question

This figure depicts response data from the following survey question: “What were the main drivers for the implementation of your BTAM program?” (n = 452). Respondents were instructed to select up to three responses.

p. 55 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 55 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 55 · click to enlarge
Fact [V] p055-09

Figure 7.1 note: Other 7 percent, Don’t know 3 percent, None of these 2 percent

Sample (N = 452) · Principals answering the implementation drivers question

Respondents were also given an “Other” option, selected by 7 percent of respondents; a “Don’t know” option, selected by 3 percent of respondents; and a “None of these were main drivers” option, selected by 2 percent of respondents.

p. 55 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 55 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 55 · click to enlarge
Fact [V] p055-10

Figure 7.1 includes only respondents with a team and model present at initial implementation

Includes only those who said their school has a school- or district-level BTAM team; that their team was using a named model that we listed, an “Other” model, or a locally created one; and that they were around for the initial implementation of this model.

p. 55 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 55 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 55 · click to enlarge
Conclusion [V] p055-12

State policy is not the determining factor in BTAM uptake by schools

The fact that BTAM programs are still very common even in those states where adoption of BTAM was neither mandated nor encouraged in 2019 further highlights the finding that state policy is not the determining factor in uptake of BTAM by schools.

p. 55 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 55 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 55 · click to enlarge
Fact [I] p055-15

Principals in early-mandate or early-encouragement states still cited best practice as a main reason

still saw BTAM as a best practice for violence prevention as a main reason for adoption.

p. 55 · NCIER Claim Map

Why inferred The sentence crosses a page break: this quote is the page 55 part and the sentence begins on page 54. Full sentence (pages 54–55): “However, a greater percentage of these principals still saw BTAM as a best practice for violence prevention as a main reason for adoption.” “These principals” are those in states that mandated BTAM early or strongly encouraged its adoption early (in 2019), per the preceding sentence on page 54.

Report page 55 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 55 · click to enlarge
Fact [V] p125-08

Table A.29: Other organizations we depend on (e.g., our local law enforcement departmen… - 8.3 / 8.2

Sample (N = 475 | 452 by column) · Table A.29 columns: Official BTAM teams and other school-based teams | Official BTAM teams only

Other organizations we depend on (e.g., our local law enforcement department) encouraged us to adopt a BTAM program | 8.3 | 8.2

p. 125 · NCIER Claim Map
Report page 125 with the cited passage highlighted
Source page 125 · click to enlarge

Top

Find the Perfect Training Class For You